is ‘urbanism without effort’ the best urbanism of all?

Real neighborhood experiences can provide a meaningful gloss on current discussions about how to make cities better and increase shared places for all.

On Saturday night, in response to an email, I went to the movies by walking 100 feet from my home. Admission was free. And it was not in the comfort of an isolated home or downtown space, but among some 20 neighbors in an everyday place, hidden and in plain sight: Monica and Michael’s alley entry, against Anne and Jerry’s retaining wall.

Our last “alley movie night” of the summer was an important reminder that a city neighborhood can experience community without really trying—an “urbanism without effort” that needs no thought leadership nor sound bytes—and is as natural as European street life in places we sometimes wish we were.

We can try awfully hard—sometimes too hard, in my opinion—to extol the virtues of the city by proselytizing and debating ideas and opportunities. In particular, the potential for American urban alleys remains in the spotlight. This attention, often aspirational, is well-deserved given the raw alley palette for remade narrow streets in the organic European tradition, pedestrian in scale, narrow, interesting and a natural focus for greening street life and new small businesses.

Recently, additional essays (e.g., Alyse Nelson writing in Sightline last week), have recalled alleys’ placemaking role within the urbanist toolbox. Specific, grant-funded work by Seattle’s Daniel Toole has emphasized the now iconic, reclaimed laneway precedent of Melbourne and beyond.

The challenges, of course, are how to pay for reclaiming and maintaining these alleys. And, as with many instances of infrastructure improvement, we must determine where and how the private sector can make a difference in implementing improvements and maintenance too costly for today’s municipal public transportation and utility agencies.

After all, it’s not just about clearing away the dumpsters. As I’ve related before in contributions to the urbanist dialogue (in myurbanist and on Seattle’s KUOW radio), public rights of way, stormwater system maintenance, pavement resurfacing and other forms of street improvement may be required in order to materially reinvent desired space.

Yet, in the meantime, there are ready and simple victories in residential alleys less known or described, where neighborhood is there for the taking.

Admittedly, not all of us have traditional alleys at our back doors (which we often treat as main entries), but those of us who do can readily avail ourselves of the once and future urbanism of alley reinvention. Those of us who don’t might find a driveway and garage to suffice for now.

Email, potluck food and drink, equipment setup, and a bedsheet-as-movie screen yield public space for community, not because of doctrine or dogma, but because it is as natural as the place next door.

The best urbanism is that which is already there to be nurtured, a practice that I highly recommend.

All images composed by the author. Click on each image for more detail.

41 thoughts on “is ‘urbanism without effort’ the best urbanism of all?

  1. Pingback: Robert W. White

  2. Pingback: SvR Design Company

  3. Pingback: Adam H.

  4. Pingback: Sigit Kusumawijaya

  5. Pingback: imam wiratmadja

  6. Pingback: Dan Gilmartin

  7. Pingback: Stephen Bird

  8. Pingback: Jan Wherren

  9. Pingback: Emile HOOGE

  10. Pingback: Engaging Cities

  11. Pingback: Rianne J. Hoeve

  12. Pingback: arquiRED Mexico

  13. Pingback: Deepa Mehta

  14. Pingback: CNT

  15. Pingback: MEDEA, Malmö Univ.

  16. Pingback: Christine Esposito

  17. Pingback: Alexandra Miller

  18. Pingback: JMazer

  19. Pingback: Tara Sturm

  20. Pingback: George Osner, AICP

  21. Pingback: David Gingras

  22. Pingback: Yuri Artibise

  23. Pingback: Scott Langley

  24. Pingback: John Olson

  25. Pingback: Ned Barrett

  26. Pingback: Lori Graham

  27. Pingback: George Dearing

  28. Pingback: Andrew Knochel

  29. Pingback: George Dearing

  30. Pingback: irishboyinlondon

  31. Pingback: irishboyinlondon

  32. Pingback: Maestrias

  33. Pingback: Kevin Varner

  34. Pingback: Bo McCarver’s weekly news compilation, 9-20-2011 | Texas housers

  35. Pingback: Island Press

  36. Pingback: Nathaniel Hood

  37. Pingback: JoAnnGreco

  38. Pingback: Urban Genesis

  39. Pingback: dan pearce

  40. Pingback: Rebecca Eggleston

  41. Pingback: Bill Nigh

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.